Tina M. Cho
  • Blog
  • About
  • Books
    • Rice from Heaven
    • Korean Celebrations
    • My Breakfast with Jesus
    • The Ocean Calls
  • School Visits
  • Work for Hire Projects
    • Other Writing Credits
  • Resources for Writers
    • Guest Blog Posts I Wrote
Picture

How I Accidentally Wrote a Graphic Novel

1/23/2020

46 Comments

 
Picture
In 2010, we moved to South Korea for my husband's work. At churches I heard about people helping North Korean escapees. I had never heard about them in the states. I researched on the Internet, reading all the articles I could find, watching You Tube videos about them. Most of the articles kept mentioning a Pastor Chun, calling him the "Schindler of Asia." So in 2012 I looked him up, found his church & school for North Korean children, and with my husband translating, I interviewed him & two North Korean boys who had recently escaped. Afterward I set out to write a picture book manuscript about this fascinating story. First draft was written November 29, 2012. It went through 16 miserable drafts with my faithful critique group Pens & Brushes, until a couple of them piped up and said I should try this as a middle grade novel.

A MG novel? I had never written one before. Another critique partner, Nancy I. Sanders, had a self-paced course "How to Write a Middle Grade Novel in One Month," which I took. I already had the basic plot line. I wrote the 21 chapters between March/April 2015. Revised 4 times with some beta-readers & used editor Cheryl Klein's book Second Sight. Then someone told me about the Scholastic Asian Book Award--submit a story about Asia, written by an Asian. That's me. I had nothing to lose. I was floored when someone contacted me that my MG novel had been shortlisted for this award, and would I fly to Singapore for the results? In May 2016, I took a day off from teaching, flew to Singapore for the Asian Festival of Children's Content conference, when I discovered the renowned picture book historian & author, Leonard Marcus, was one of the judges! My MG novel titled at that time, Chasing Freedom: The Asian Underground Railroad, won 2nd place, or what they called 1st Runner Up. Scholastic Asia wanted to publish. I blogged about that experience here.

After receiving the contract from Scholastic Asia, I didn't feel that it was right for me and my story. $500SG + few edits. I knew that since it was my first novel, it needed a lot of work. After talking to many professionals in the industry, I passed.

In December 2016, I signed with my wonderful agent, Adria Goetz, who loved a couple of my picture book manuscripts. I told her about this novel, and she agreed to help. From 2017-2018 I revised with Adria. She sent it out to editors, and they sent back rejections. I revised per their suggestions. She sent it out again. 11 rejections. Then Adria had a wild idea. Try writing it as a novel in verse. She had just sold one, and my previous picture book, RICE FROM HEAVEN: THE SECRET MISSION TO FEED NORTH KOREANS was written as a lyrical picture book. Adria knows my writing better than me. I loved reading novels in verse but had never written one.

So I read the great novel in verse authors' works that I could get my hands on, checked them out from the library when I was in the states during summer, even took an SCBWI Novel in Verse webinar with author K.A. Holt. During the latter part of 2018 - beginning of 2019 I worked on rewriting this as poetry. 

Until March 2019, I sort of QUIT. I was depressed. Who was I to try to write a novel in verse? or a MG? I don't classify myself as a poet. Some parts of the story just weren't coming together. Being across the ocean from my agent, somehow Adria could sense something was wrong. She emailed me to have a phone chat in April. Just what I needed. Adria was such an encourager, a believer in me & my writing, and gave me a great pep talk & kick in the pants, so to speak. 

With encouragement & prayers, I finished the 5th novel in verse revision that May, and we changed the title to The Tune without Words b/c there was already another book with my previous title. She sent it out to editors. In June editor Carolina from Harper Collins asked if we were interested in publishing it as a lyrical novel in verse GRAPHIC NOVEL. 

A graphic novel?! Truthfully, I had only read 1 previous graphic novel of my niece's--one of Raina Telgemeier's books. I'm not really into say-- superhero graphic novels & comics. (no offense!) I did read comics growing up, The Sunday Funnies like Peanuts, Garfield, Dennis the Menace, Cathy, etc...

But graphic novels have changed! Blogging friends showcased graphic novels that were being published about historical topics and nonfiction. Articles are being written on the effects of students reading them in the classroom. While in Iowa during the summer, one that I really liked was HIDDEN: A CHILD'S STORY OF THE HOLOCAUST written by Loic Dauvillier & Greg Salsedo, illustrated by Marc Lizano. So I told Adria, yes, let's go for it.

The editor from Harper Collins found an illustrator, Deborah Lee, a Korean American illustrator in CA, who would illustrate a sample poem so we could get an idea. She sent illustration samples in August. I fell in love with the characters & color palette. It was so poignant & made me cry. I want children in the U.S. and around the world to know that as we speak--some kids in N.K. are escaping or living hidden in China. With Deb's illustrations, this story will really come to life and especially bring out the cultural aspects that people might not be familiar with. 

I signed the contract in November, my biggest yet, & received first edits in December which I submitted & will continue to revise until it's perfecto! Carolina has been a wonderful editor for this story.

But even better--God has perfect timing. I've been wanting this story to be out in the world, but it wasn't the time yet. Most of you know I teach at an international school in S.Korea. I've wanted them to do a service ministry with North Korean refugees but it never worked out, until now! The same North Korean school run by Pastor Chun agreed to have some of our high school students come in March to do an English camp with their 40 North Korean children. I'm one of the teachers on the team. And now I can share with him that this story finally sold & will become reality in 2022!  God is good. His timing is perfect. 

Sorry to ramble on and on, but don't give up on your story. If you believe that it needs to be told, find the best format/genre/style, take classes, study the craft, and it will get out into the world ❤️
46 Comments
Trine Grillo
1/23/2020 07:55:30 pm

Tina, this is wonderful!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:56:20 am

Thanks, Trine!

Reply
Mirka Breen link
1/23/2020 10:01:58 pm

Yes, Tina girl, YOU DID IT :) and it was worth doing! More than anything, it is a book the world needs to read

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:56:50 am

Yay, Mirka, it finally worked. Thank you for believing in this story!

Reply
Nancy I. Sanders link
1/23/2020 10:26:18 pm

Tina, I am rejoicing at God’s goodness! And also what an inspirational example you are to us as writers! So excited for you in so many ways!!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:57:23 am

Thank you, Nancy, for teaching me how to write/get published!

Reply
Kathy Halsey
1/24/2020 06:22:41 am

Tina, this is an amazing story of perseverance and talent. I a not a big GN fan, but I really wanton read this.

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:27:17 pm

And truthfully, Kathy, neither am/was I. But I think this one will be very different.

Reply
Darshana Khiani link
1/24/2020 09:06:36 am

Wow! What a journey it's been and so inspiring. Thank you for sharing. I'm so glad you stuck with it. :-)

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:27:43 pm

Thanks, Darshana. Never give up!

Reply
Vivian Kirkfield link
1/24/2020 09:15:39 am

Oh Tina! I am so very proud and happy for you! Thank you for sharing all of the behind the scenes highs and lows...this is helpful for all of us, no matter what we are writing. Congratulations!!! And I can't wait to get a copy and share it with my grandkids!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:28:24 pm

Ah, thanks, Vivian. There are always highs & lows!

Reply
Penny Parker Klosterman link
1/24/2020 11:34:37 am

Tina! This is so wonderful. And I loved reading about your journey and your persistence! And how this manuscript evolved. Congratulations!!!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:29:07 pm

Thanks, Penny! I loved seeing your board books on Facebook. How neat to see this book doing so well!

Reply
Margaret E Albertson
1/24/2020 02:37:49 pm

Tina, I am rejoicing with you. God is good. His timing is perfect. You have always inspired me! This is a must read book. I will get it into the hands of my grands. Margaret

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 03:29:42 pm

Thanks, Margaret. And you inspire me!

Reply
Laura Sassi link
1/24/2020 05:38:12 pm

Wow! What an amazing story of hard work, persistence, and trusting in God's timing. I absolutely cannot wait to read this and add it to my "Books by Tina Cho" collection.

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/24/2020 05:45:03 pm

Ah, thanks, Laura. How funny--we collect our CPs books on our shelves!

Reply
Jilanne Hoffmann
1/25/2020 05:46:17 pm

Yours is a wonderful and inspiring story, Tina! Congrats after all that hard work! All the best to you!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/26/2020 09:46:08 pm

Thanks so much, Jilanne!

Reply
Diane Tulloch link
1/25/2020 06:18:17 pm

Wo! I am soooooo happy and proud of you Tina. This is an amazing story and I can't wait to see it finally in print. I remember your changing it to free verse and then to graphic novel and the doubts you had. But you have done an amazing job and I can't wait to get my hands on a copy. Congratulations dear Tina.

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/26/2020 09:46:51 pm

And thank you, Diane, for being a beta reader & giving valuable insight!

Reply
Evelyn Christensen link
1/26/2020 12:34:19 pm

Tina, what a wonderfully inspiring testimony of using your writing gifts to serve God. I'm so happy for you that your story has finally found the right publisher and right format. Congratulations to you!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/26/2020 09:47:27 pm

Thank you, Ev! I'm excited to see how God will use this!

Reply
Savannah Rogers
1/26/2020 05:56:20 pm

This is an amazing, encouraging article, thank you so much for sharing your journey with us!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/26/2020 09:47:57 pm

I'm glad it encouraged you, Savannah. Happy writing!

Reply
Jarm Del Boccio link
1/27/2020 07:25:50 pm

Wow. This is tremendous news, Tina. So excited for you!! And yes, God has perfect timing. He knows what is best. My word for this year is CONTENTMENT. I want to be content with whatever He brings (or doesn't bring) my way. Congrats and blessings!!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/29/2020 04:44:29 am

Great word, Jarm. Thanks for sharing!

Reply
Dee Knabb
1/30/2020 01:39:24 am

Thanks for working so hard, Tina. This is an important story for kids to read. Congratulations on the book. Your exhaustive work paid off!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/30/2020 04:18:38 am

Thanks so much, Dee!

Reply
Melissa Stoller link
1/30/2020 04:06:46 am

What a journey, Tina! Thanks for this inspiration to keep going and try different styles and genres! I look forward to reading this book!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/30/2020 04:19:14 am

Thanks for stopping by, Melissa!

Reply
Rebecca Hirsch link
1/30/2020 05:35:48 am

So proud of you, Tina! What a long journey! I think other writers will be encouraged to hear that— yes, sometimes it takes this long. I can't wait to read this book!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/30/2020 12:46:28 pm

Thank you, Rebecca, and for your insight into the very beginning.

Reply
Jean Matthew Hall link
1/30/2020 06:37:29 am

Such a beautiful and exciting story! Thank you for sharing your journey. Blessings!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/30/2020 12:46:58 pm

Thank you, Jean, for stopping by!

Reply
Catherine Osornio link
1/30/2020 08:38:48 pm

Congratulations, Tina! God is really blessing you. I think we met a LONG time ago at one of Nancy's meetings before you moved to South Korea. She mentions you now and again in our conversations. It's great to see how you are progressing in your writing career :)

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/31/2020 02:35:03 am

Hi Catherine, Yes, I remember you! It's been a long time. Good to hear from you. Thanks for stopping by my blog!

Reply
Diane Stortz link
1/31/2020 07:06:56 am

Loved reading about this journey. Your perseverance is inspiring!

Reply
Tina Cho link
1/31/2020 05:03:21 pm

Thanks so much, Diane! Happy writing.

Reply
Mindy Baker link
2/1/2020 07:15:37 am

Thank you for sharing your journey. I can't wait to see the finished product. It sounds wonderful!

Reply
Tina Cho link
2/1/2020 09:18:43 pm

Thanks so much, Mindy!

Reply
Gloria Stockstill
2/8/2020 03:30:22 pm

Great article, Tina. So happy for you.

Reply
Tina Cho link
2/9/2020 03:32:11 am

Thanks so much, Gloria!

Reply
Kim-Hoa Ung
10/11/2021 02:51:43 pm

Hi, Tina! This is so inspirational. I am so happy for you. I can't wait to read your amazing graphic novel. I would love to write one too about my father's journey but I'm not sure how to start. Do you have a recommendation on what novel in verse to study? I'm not a poetic person but I'd love to learn. Thank you and congratulations :)

Reply
MckinneyVia link
2/23/2022 11:31:25 pm

What an exquisite article! Your post is very helpful right now. Thank you for sharing this informative one.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Picture

    Tina M. Cho, children's author

    I'm a children's author and freelance writer for the educational market. Welcome!

    Picture

    Archives

    November 2022
    July 2022
    February 2022
    October 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

    Click here to read previous posts at my old blog.

    Categories

    All
    Adria Goetz
    Agent Interview
    Asian American Women In Science
    Asian Festival Of Children's Content
    Audio Book
    Author Brand
    Author Email Signature
    Author Life
    Author Platform
    Author Presentation
    Author Signing
    Author Skypes
    Authors On Social Media
    Author Visits
    Award Winning Book
    BIC
    Book Birthday
    Booklist Review
    Book Query
    Book Reviews
    Books About Diversity
    Books About Inclusion
    Book Signing
    Breakfasts Around The World
    Chapter Book Series
    Children's Day
    Choices Christian Bookstore
    Common Core Book Activities
    Common Core Standards And Nonfiction Text
    Cora Cooks Pancit
    Coronavirus Korea
    Creating Extension Activities For Your Book
    Cynthea Liu's Critiques
    Difference Between Picture Books And Novels
    Different Like Me
    Diverse Books
    Diverse Christian Authors
    Diverse Picture Books
    Diversity
    Dorena Williamson
    Dorina Lazo Gilmore-Young
    Faith Based Diverse Picture Books
    Faith-based Diverse Picture Books
    F&Gs
    Filipino Picture Book
    Focused Writing
    Focus Words
    Fonts And Clip Art
    Global Picture Books
    Goals
    Guided Reading Levels
    Haenyeo
    Hans Christian Andersen Award
    Harvest House
    How I Got My Agent
    How To Create An Educational Product
    How To Get An Agent
    How To Land An Agent
    How To Write A Lesson Plan For Your Book
    How To Write A Lyrical Picture Book
    How To Write A Picture Book Biography
    How To Write A Rebus
    How To Write For The Christian Market
    How To Write For The Educational Market
    How To Write Picture Book Activities
    Instagram Live
    Interview Joshua Hawkins
    Interview With Evelyn Christensen
    Interview With Hannah Holt
    Interview With Laura Murray
    Interview With Marie Harris
    Interview With Nancy I. Sanders
    Kibooka
    Kindergarten
    Kirkus Reviews
    Kokila
    Korean Celebrations
    Korean Holidays
    Korea's Independence Movement Day
    Landing A Book Contract
    Lexile
    Literary Christmas
    Little Bee
    Little Free Library
    Martin Literary
    Molly Holt
    Mother's Day
    Multicultural Writing
    My Breakfast With Jesus
    Nami Island
    New Year
    Nonfiction Picture Book Online Class
    North Korea
    North Korean Refugees
    Online Learning
    Own Voices
    Paid Critiques
    Pancit
    Parent's Day
    Piboidmo
    Picture Book Agent
    Picture Book Ideas
    Picture Book Island
    Picture Book Look Podcast
    Picture Book Subtitles
    Picture Book Timeline
    Pottery Barn Kids Instagram
    Preorder
    Professional Critiques
    Proverbs 16:3
    Publisher's Weekly Review
    Representation Matters
    Researching A Biography
    Rice Balloon Project
    Rice Form Heaven
    Rice From Heaven
    Rosemary Wells Lecture
    Scholastic Asian Book Award
    School Visits
    Self-publish E-book
    Social Media For Writers
    South Korea
    South Korea's Holidays
    Summer Activities For Writers
    Summer Author Visits
    Teachers Pay Teachers
    The Celebration Place
    The Girl's Guide To Manners
    The Ocean Calls
    Tuttle Publishing
    Twitter For Writers
    Using Twitter To Promote Books
    Virtual Author Visits
    Why Instagram For Writers
    Why Write Children's Books
    Why Writers Should Be On Social Media
    Word For The Year
    World Read Aloud Day
    Writer's Courage
    Writers In Summer
    Writing About Culture
    Writing A Graphic Novel
    Writing An Endorsement For A Book
    Writing A Novel
    Writing A Subtitle
    Writing Back Matter
    Writing Behaviors
    Writing Conference
    Writing Guided Reading Books
    Writing Picture Books
    Writing Priorities
    Writing Tips
    Xochitl Dixon

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Blog
  • About
  • Books
    • Rice from Heaven
    • Korean Celebrations
    • My Breakfast with Jesus
    • The Ocean Calls
  • School Visits
  • Work for Hire Projects
    • Other Writing Credits
  • Resources for Writers
    • Guest Blog Posts I Wrote